Composting is a sustainable practice that not only reduces household waste but also creates nutrient-rich soil for your garden. Choosing the right compost bin is essential to streamline the composting process and achieve optimal results. Here are the top five compost bins that stand out for their functionality, durability, and eco-friendly features.

UK Compost Bin Reviews

Envirocycle The Most Beautiful Composter in The World

The Envirocycle composter is not just a practical solution; it’s also an aesthetic addition to your garden. This compact, drum-style composter boasts a sleek design and a durable construction. Its unique feature is the compost tea collecting base, which allows you to gather nutrient-rich liquid to nourish your plants. With its ease of use and ability to produce compost in as little as 4 to 6 weeks, it’s a top choice for both beginners and experienced composters.

Yimby Tumbler Composter

The Yimby Tumbler Composter is a favorite among gardeners who value simplicity and efficiency. This dual-chamber composter allows you to compost continuously while the other chamber matures. The tumbling design makes turning the compost effortless, ensuring proper aeration for faster decomposition. With sturdy construction and a capacity of 37 gallons, the Yimby Tumbler is ideal for those with smaller yards or limited space.

FCMP Outdoor IM4000 Tumbling Composter

The FCMP Outdoor IM4000 is a heavy-duty tumbling composter that accelerates the composting process. Its dual-chamber design enables batch composting, letting one chamber decompose while the other is actively receiving new waste. With a large capacity of 37 gallons and BPA-free construction, it’s an excellent choice for gardeners who generate a significant amount of kitchen and yard waste.

Gardener’s Supply Company Deluxe Pyramid Composter

The Gardener’s Supply Company Deluxe Pyramid Composter stands out for its innovative pyramid shape, which promotes efficient composting. The open-bottom design allows direct contact with the soil, encouraging beneficial organisms to aid in decomposition. This composter is particularly suitable for gardeners who want an attractive composting solution that blends seamlessly into their outdoor space.

Miracle-Gro Small Composter – Compact Single Chamber Outdoor Garden Compost Bin

For those with limited space, the Miracle-Gro Small Composter offers a compact and efficient composting solution. This single-chamber composter is designed for easy assembly and use. The aeration and mixing system ensure that your compost breaks down quickly, producing nutrient-rich humus for your plants. Its affordability and user-friendly design make it an excellent choice for beginners or anyone with a modest composting needs.

  • Compost Bin Testing Methodology

Our Team of Product Testers:

  • Iain Pay

At Garden Yard, recognizing the pivotal role of a dependable compost bin, we conducted a rigorous testing process to provide you with the most precise and reliable information. Our evaluation focused on various aspects:

1. Assembly Process:

We initiated our assessment by scrutinizing the assembly process of each compost bin. Models requiring no assembly or featuring an effortless setup within 10 minutes received the highest ratings. Any assembly duration exceeding 15 minutes was considered impractical for the average gardener. We also took note of any challenges encountered during assembly, such as the need for forceful connections or intricate attachments. Models facing such issues received lower ratings.

2. Design:

Compost bins must withstand adverse weather conditions, including strong winds. We subjected the bins to these conditions, awarding higher ratings to products that exhibited resilience in storms. Bins constructed from robust, heavy-duty plastic received superior ratings compared to those made from thinner plastic or wood. The ability to endure extreme weather without deterioration or toppling over was a crucial criterion.

3. Features:

Square bins earned top marks for their ease of loading and superior tessellation. Bins with effective sealing, a solid base, and small ventilation holes garnered higher ratings, emphasizing their importance in preventing rodent access. We prioritized rat-proof qualities in our assessment.

4. Ease of Use:

Evaluating the ease of use involved assessing the functionality of each compost bin’s features. For instance, we observed the efficiency of sliding doors and checked for any issues with tumbling mechanisms. Bins featuring removable front hatches received higher ratings, as these attributes significantly enhanced the loading and unloading processes.

5. Value for Money:

Our determination of value for money took into account the durability, useful features, and overall user-friendliness of the compost bins. Models with robust designs and user-friendly features often commanded higher prices, but if the cost was reasonable in relation to the benefits offered, we assigned them higher ratings.

By employing this comprehensive testing methodology, DIY Garden aimed to provide you with well-informed insights into the performance, durability, and overall value of each compost bin, ensuring you can make an educated decision for your gardening needs.

Guide to Buying the Perfect Garden Compost Bin

Composting your garden and kitchen waste is not just an eco-friendly practice; it’s a gift to your garden, enriching it with nutrient-packed compost. When choosing a compost bin, several factors come into play to ensure you pick the right one for your specific needs.

Consider the Purpose:

  1. For Leaves Only:
    • Opt for mesh-sided compost bins, which are not only affordable but ideal for composting leaves.
  2. Composting Food Scraps:
    • Choose an enclosed bin with solid sides and small ventilation holes to prevent pests.
    • A built-in base can deter rodents from entering from underneath.

Bin Size Matters:

  1. Small Family/Kitchen Waste:

    • A 150 L capacity bin is suitable for smaller families primarily composting kitchen waste.
  2. Larger Family/Garden Waste:

    • Opt for a 220 L or larger bin if you have a larger family or want to compost garden waste.

Easy Turning:

  1. Consider Bin Shape:
    • Conical bins should have a top opening of at least 20 cm for easy turning; square bins are more accessible and convenient.

Top Recommendations:

  1. Garden Point Tumbling Composter:
    • Ideal for kitchen waste with a built-in turning mechanism.
  2. 4smile Compost Bin:
    • Sturdy and wind-proof, proven after enduring Storm Arwen’s 65 mph winds.

How to Choose the Best Compost Bin:

Bins for Different Uses:

  • For Food Scraps:

    • Opt for an enclosed bin with solid sides and small ventilation holes.
    • Consider a model with a built-in base to prevent pests.
  • In Windy Areas:

    • Choose a bin with a wide base for stability.
    • Lower bins with a lower center of gravity are less likely to topple.
    • Look for bins that can be secured to the ground or a wall.
  • Bulk Composting:

    • Select a wide open-top bin with a large capacity for bulk composting.
    • Avoid bins with small openings that make it challenging to insert larger clippings.

Construction Material:

  • Wood:

    • Aesthetically pleasing, blends with the garden.
    • Slatted designs offer excellent aeration.
    • Heavier than plastic, requires regular treatment to prevent rotting.
  • Plastic:

    • Lightweight and easy to assemble.
    • Dark color traps heat, aiding composting.
    • Some designs may not be as aesthetically pleasing as wooden ones.

Design Features:

  • Bin Shape:

    • Square bins tessellate better and are easier to load.
    • Consider preferences between the convenience of square bins and the aesthetics of round ones.
  • Lid Design:

    • Screw-on lids retain heat well but can be challenging to handle.
    • Hinged lids are convenient for one-handed operation.
    • No lid allows easy loading but may result in slower composting.
  • Rat-Proofing:

    • Choose a bin with a base or place it on concrete slabs.
    • Ensure the bin is well-sealed, and ventilation holes are too small for rodents.

By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision and choose a compost bin that perfectly aligns with your gardening goals. Happy composting! 🌿🗑️

Looking for a compost aerator? Then check out this review.


By selecting the right compost bin based on your specific requirements, you can embark on a rewarding composting journey, contributing to both environmental sustainability and the health of your garden.

About The Author